Massachusetts Association of Realtors Home
  • About
    • About MAR

      Our mission

      Contact Us 

      Contact MAR   

      Become a Realtor®

      What you need to know to join MAR   

      MAR Charitable Foundation

      Realtors® giving back to the community

      Local Realtor® Associations

      Find the local Realtor® Association closest to you

      Association Leadership Team

      Meet the volunteer leaders of MAR

      Association Professional Staff

      Meet the professional staff that helps manage the Association


      Realtor Search Function Powered by realtor.com
      Find a Realtor

      Find a REALTOR®

  • Members
    • Forms

      Industry-leading Ziplogix™

      Market Data

      Comprehensive sales data covering Massachusetts

      Association Governance

      How the Association runs

      Member Benefits

      Your gateway to education, services, and discounts

      Sharable Content

      Free, sharable resources

      Education

      Classes, webinars and online continuing education

      New Members

      Information for new MAR members 

      Calendar

      Find upcoming classes, meetings and other events

      Government Affairs

      Federal, state and local issues that impact real estate

      MAR Podcasts

      Home of all MAR Podcasts

      Legal and Ethics

      Understand the latest laws and right way to conduct business

      Committees

      Member-led committees that guide MAR

      Report an Issue

      How can we improve?

      Profile

      Your MAR Member Info

      Log In

      MAR Members, click to Log In

  • Public
    • Realtor® Logo
      Why Work With a Realtor®

      Code of Ethics

      Get to know the Realtor® difference

      Buyer and Seller Tips

      Buying or selling a home? Here's what you need to know

      First-Time Homebuyer?

      Are you a first-time homebuyer? We're here to help  

      Market Data

      Comprehensive sales data covering Massachusetts

      Find a Realtor®

      Realtor search function powered by realtor.com 

      Become a Realtor®

      What you need to know to join MAR

      Become an Agent

      Not a Realtor® yet? Start your path to becoming a Realtor® today

      MAR Gratitude Project

      Nominate the unsung heroes of the Realtor® community
      facebook_sqaure__1_
      2020 Installation of Officers
  • News
    • BSR_Nov_Dec19_NavBay State Realtor®

      MAR Online

      The official blog of MAR

      From the Bay State Realtor®

      Stories and articles from the official print publication of MAR

      Press Releases

      The latest news and information from MAR
      FAQFeatured Blog Post



05.01.2019|

Zillow Talk

Zillow has become a dominant player in the real estate marketplace in ways that few imagined when it began publishing formulaic valuations of residences little more than a decade ago. Similar to companies like Google and Facebook, Zillow was able to convert its business model into an advertising goldmine. Over the course of the last several years, that goldmine was threatened by investigations and lawsuits targeting Zillow’s property valuations and marketing practices. Although the final word may not yet be in, for now, Zillow appears to have fought off these challenges.
by Stephen M. Perry, ESQ., Casner & Edwards, LLP

The Algorithm:


The lifeblood of Zillow’s business is its proprietary algorithm for valuing residential properties. Because they are based largely on public information such as assessments, prior sales, and square footage, these valuations may fail to reflect individual features of a home. When they are off, they can be upsetting not only to homeowners, but also to real estate professionals, who have to manage their clients’ expectations based on actual market conditions, rather than a value created by an algorithm.

In 2017, aggrieved property owners brought a class action lawsuit in Illinois, complaining that Zillow was publishing unfairly low valuations of their properties, which the company refused to remove or correct. But last year, the federal district court dismissed the class action, holding that Zillow’s published opinions of value were held as just that –opinions. And, in February of this year, the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit affirmed the dismissal. Unless the law of some other state proves to be less hospitable, it appears that the Zestimates® are here to stay.

Consumer Financial Protection Bureau:

A more serious threat to Zillow’s business practices came from an investigation launched a few years ago by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFBP) concerning Zillow’s co-marketing program, which supplemented its “premium agent” program. Under the “premium agent” program, agents pay Zillow to be listed alongside real estate that is for sale and to receive leads from Zillow when consumers enter their information on the website. Under the co-marketing program, added in 2013, mortgage lenders could pay to appear on the same page as the real estate agents. The lenders’ payments to Zillow—the amount of which were negotiated between the real estate agents and the lenders—reduced the amount that the real estate agents had to pay to Zillow.

The CFPB was concerned that these practices might violate the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (“RESPA”). RESPA generally makes it illegal—a federal crime—for a real estate broker to receive any form of compensation from a lender in return for referring mortgage business. One potential concern was that Zillow’s program, as actually conducted, might be a backdoor way for brokers to endorse and refer customers to their co-marketing lenders in return for those lenders agreeing to subsidize the agents’ expenses of advertising on Zillow. Zillow’s stock dropped15 percent once the CFPB investigation was disclosed. In turn, shareholders brought a securities class action case against Zillow alleging that it had injured investors by fraudulently misrepresenting the lawfulness of its co-marketing program.

Last year, Zillow achieved victories on both of these fronts. First, in June 2018, the CFPB, under Director of the Office of Management and Budget’s Mick Mulvaney’s more business-friendly leadership, dropped its investigation into Zillow. And later in 2018, the federal district court dismissed the shareholders’ securities claim, finding that the complaint did not sufficiently allege that Zillow had violated RESPA– and even less that it knew it had violated RESPA, as would be required to establish a fraud claim. The plaintiffs recently amended their complaint in an attempt to meet the shortcomings identified by the court, but they are likely paddling upstream.

Future of Co-Marketing:

Does Zillow’s successful defense to date mean that brokers who sign up for Zillow’s co-marketing program are entirely in the clear? Not necessarily. No doubt the risks have lessened, especially because Zillow has already changed some of its co-marketing procedures in light of the CFPB claim. But participating brokers still need to make sure that any co-marketing arrangements that they enter into with lenders, whether carried out on Zillow or otherwise, comply with the anti-kickback provisions of RESPA.

Parties to a lawfully constructed co-marketing arrangement can share advertising costs, but it remains unlawful under RESPA for a broker to receive compensation from a lender that is explicitly or implicitly provided in return for the broker’s referral of business to a lender. The CFPB is likely to be unaggressive in pursuing these issues under the current administration, but there is still the possibility of private claims or a change in the CFPB’s leadership down the road.

“Zillow Offers”:


Meanwhile, get ready for the next phase of Zillow’s business expansion. Last year the company launched its a “Zillow offers” program in a number of test markets, including Raleighand Charlotte, NC., Denver, Phoenix, Atlanta, and Las Vegas. Under this program, the company will be using its valuation algorithm to make offers to buy residential properties, which it will then fix up and resell.

Zillow also recently purchased a mortgage company, which can assist in financing these or other sales. The company is also procuring a broker’s license in states, such as Arizona, where, in view of these new activities, the licensing law requires it to do so. But Zillow has reassured its Premier Agents that it intends to use them and to pay them or their firms a commission in connection with its purchase and sale of properties. Only time will tell how all of this affects the industry, and whether this expansion of the company’s business will lead to yet more legal and regulatory issues.
 

Leave a comment
Newest on top Oldest on top
Load more comments
comment-avatar
|

mar_online_logo

MAR Online is your home for the latest news impacting the real estate industry. Get up-to-date information on the housing market, legislative happenings on Beacon Hill, and national trends. Find all the content in our print publication Bay State Realtor® plus online exclusives, press releases, and perspectives from MAR staff.

Latest Issue of Bay State Realtor® Magazine:

BSR Cover Nov-Dec 2019

Tagged Posts: 

  • Anne Meczywor (3)
  • Bay State Realtor (63)
  • Blog (3)
  • BSR (1)
  • Catherine Taylor (2)
  • Day on the hill (1)
  • Foreclosure (1)
  • Government Affairs (5)
  • July August (8)
  • Justin Davidson (7)
  • Legal (1)
  • Press Releases (32)
  • Realtor Advocate (1)
  • Rita-Coffey (1)
  • September October (11)
  • State Political Coodinators (1)
  • State Political Coordinators (1)
  • Theresa Hatton (1)
MAR Logo
©2019 Massachusetts Association of Realtors
Privacy | Terms of Use | Report an Issue
MAR Facebook Page MAR Twitter Page MAR Linkedin Page MAR Youtube Page MAR Instagram Page MAR Pintrest Page
Realtors Badge